The Bills suffered a 33-30 overtime loss to the Broncos in last weekend’s divisional round, the franchise’s latest crushing playoff defeat. Sean McDermott was at the helm for several of those losses, and owner Terry Pegula elected to make a change in firing the head coach on Monday.
A Super Bowl appearance eluded McDermott, but his nine-year run was nonetheless a success. Taking over an organization that had missed the postseason 17 straight times, McDermott guided the Bills to the playoffs in eight of nine seasons. He went 98-50 in the regular season, 8-8 in the playoffs and won five AFC East titles.
McDermott, then the Panthers’ defensive coordinator, took the Buffalo job in January 2017. Former Panthers colleague Brandon Beane became the Bills’ GM four months later.
Not only is Beane still in place despite McDermott’s ouster, but Pegula promoted him to president of football operations/GM on Monday. Beane is now leading the search for McDermott’s replacement.
Five weeks before the Bills cut ties with McDermott, he expressed concerns over the roster in a meeting with Pegula and Beane, Vic Carucci of Sirius XM Radio reports. McDermott pointed out certain ingredients the Bills were missing to win a Super Bowl, which left Pegula and Beane displeased. Pegula publicly stood up for Beane’s roster when discussing McDermott’s firing on Wednesday.
“Great roster,” he said (via Cameron Wolfe of NFL Network). “Good coaching. No Super Bowls… how do we overcome this? One year after another. I just couldn’t see us doing that with Sean (McDermott). That’s why I relieved him.”
It’s unknown which positions McDermott brought up in the meeting, though wide receiver, the run defense, the pass rush and a banged-up secondary were among areas of inconsistency for the team during the season. Beane didn’t make any deals to address the Bills’ weaknesses before the Nov. 4 trade deadline, instead bringing in receiver Brandin Cooks in free agency three weeks later and claiming defensive back Darnell Savage off waivers in early December.
The Savage addition came after the Bills’ claiming of former Steeler Darius Slay blew up in their faces. Slay didn’t report to the Bills, who placed him on the reserve/retired list. Assuming they’d get Slay, the Bills cut Ja’Marcus Ingram and then saw him join the Texans on waivers. McDermott was irked over losing Ingram, a member of the Bills from 2022-25.
“I’m a huge Ja’Marcus Ingram fan, and will always be,” said McDermott. “I want the best for him, so that’s really where my mind is right now.”
Cooks and Savage ended up playing important roles in Buffalo’s loss to Denver, and not in a good way for the Bills. Savage, subbing in during a minor Cam Lewis injury, was burned for a 29-yard touchdown pass near the end of the first half, The Broncos took a 17-10 lead on that score and later went up by double digits, but the Bills fought back to force overtime.
With the game tied at 30 in OT and the Bills driving for the win, Cooks was unable to haul in a Josh Allen deep ball that could have propelled the team to the AFC title game. In one of the most controversial plays of the season, Broncos cornerback Ja’Quan McMillian wrestled the ball from Cooks and came away with an interception. The Bills likely would have set up for the winning field goal had it been ruled a catch; instead, their season and the McDermott era are over.
Pegula told the media he decided to part with McDermott after entering a despondent postgame locker room in Denver. The owner concluded the Bills hit“the proverbial playoff wall” and needed to go in another direction (via Alaina Getzenberg of ESPN).
Pegula also revealed that Allen, who has spent his entire eight-year career under McDermott, had no say in the decision (via Wolfe)
“He didn’t have any input at all,” Pegula said. “I didn’t talk to Josh about this. I talked to him after and that convo will stay private but he had no input in it.”
Allen appreciated his run with McDermott, but the reigning MVP continues to have faith in Pegula and Beane, Jay Skurski of the Buffalo News relays. As the face of the franchise, Allen will be involved in the coaching search, per Pegula (via Getzenberg).
Considering Allen is under center and the Bills are coming off their seventh straight season of double-digit wins, Pegula is confident he won’t have any problems landing a capable successor to McDermott. Although Allen will turn 30 in May and still hasn’t won a Super Bowl as he nears the back nine of his career, Pegula won’t tell the next head coach the team’s in championship-or-bust mode in 2026 (via Mike Florio of Pro Football Talk).
“I don’t know about pressure right now, but there’s a lot of people that want to look at taking this job,” Pegula said. “There’s a lot of interest.”
With Allen aiding Pegula, Beane and other Bills bigwigs in their head coaching search, here’s their early list of candidates:
- Lou Anarumo, defensive coordinator (Colts): Interview requested
- Joe Brady, offensive coordinator (Bills): Interviewed 1/21
- Brian Daboll, former head coach (Giants): To interview
- Klint Kubiak, offensive coordinator (Seahawks): Rumored candidate
- Anthony Lynn, run-game coordinator (Commanders): To interview 1/24
- Grant Udinski, offensive coordinator (Jaguars): Interview requested
- Anthony Weaver, defensive coordinator (Dolphins): Interview requested
- Davis Webb, quarterbacks coach (Broncos): Rumored candidate
Six of those eight coaches come from the offensive side of the ball. Allen has enjoyed success under Brady and Daboll, and he’s known to have good relationships with the pair. Teammates from 2019-21, Allen and Webb have been close friends for several years.